ML Interview Q Series: How can you use a vectorized method to assign values to the diagonal of a matrix in MATLAB?
📚 Browse the full ML Interview series here.
Comprehensive Explanation
A common situation in MATLAB is when you want to set or modify the diagonal elements of a matrix without resorting to explicit loops. By taking advantage of MATLAB’s linear indexing, you can vectorize this operation in a very efficient way. In one-based indexing (the default in MATLAB), the main diagonal elements of an n-by-n matrix A are positioned at linear indices (n+1) increments, starting from the first element (index 1). This means that the first diagonal element is at linear index 1, the second at n+2, and so forth, up to the nth diagonal element at n(n+1).
Below is the core formula for the linear index of the i-th diagonal element in a square n-by-n matrix. Here i runs from 1 to n.
Where:
i is the row (and column) index of the diagonal element in one-based indexing.
n is the total number of rows (and columns) in the square matrix.
Index(i) is the linear index in MATLAB.
Once you know these indices, you can assign a value or a vector of values to the diagonal. For example, if you have a matrix A of size n-by-n and you want to assign a vector v of size n to the diagonal, you can do something like:
A(1:n+1:end) = v
which is a concise and vectorized way to perform the assignment in MATLAB. It uses the fact that (1:n+1:end) automatically generates the linear indices for the main diagonal.
Practical Example Using Python Syntax
Although the question is about MATLAB, here is a small Python example using NumPy to illustrate the same concept of assigning values to the diagonal in a vectorized manner. This parallels MATLAB’s approach but uses zero-based indexing instead of one-based indexing:
import numpy as np
# Create a 4x4 zero matrix
A = np.zeros((4, 4))
# Define a vector of length 4
v = np.array([10, 20, 30, 40])
# Assign values to the diagonal in a vectorized way
# In Python (NumPy), the indices are 0-based, so we use np.arange(4) for both row and column
A[np.arange(4), np.arange(4)] = v
print(A)
Here, np.arange(4) gives us [0,1,2,3], which are the row and column indices of the diagonal elements in a 4-by-4 array. In MATLAB, this mirrors the use of 1:n+1:end for linear indexing on the diagonal, though with an offset because MATLAB uses 1-based indexing.
Additional Considerations
When vectorizing diagonal assignment, be mindful of the following:
Matrix Dimensions and Vector Length Ensure your vector’s length matches the dimension of the square matrix. If n is the size of the matrix, your diagonal-assignment vector should also be of length n, or if it is scalar, it will just replicate the single value across the diagonal.
Different Diagonals The main diagonal is often referred to as A(1:n+1:end) in MATLAB. If you want to assign to sub-diagonals or super-diagonals, you need to offset your indexing scheme accordingly.
Non-Square Matrices If you use linear indexing in a rectangular matrix (m-by-n), be cautious about how the rows and columns map to the linear indices. For the main diagonal of a rectangular matrix, a general approach is sub2ind or logical indexing with eye(min(m,n)) carefully placed.
Performance Vectorized operations in MATLAB are typically faster than loops. However, for extremely large matrices, memory layout and caching can also influence performance. Still, vectorized indexing is the recommended MATLAB approach for clarity and speed in most use cases.
Potential Follow-Up Questions
How do you handle diagonal assignments if the matrix is not square?
For an m-by-n matrix (m not necessarily equal to n), the linear indexing still increments by (m+1) when you move from one diagonal element to the next if you assume it’s the main diagonal (i.e., A(i,i) for i=1 to the smallest dimension). However, if the matrix is rectangular, you must ensure that i does not exceed the smaller of m or n. A more general way is to use:
A(sub2ind([m,n], 1:k, 1:k)) = v
where k is min(m,n), ensuring the indexing remains valid.
What about assigning values to diagonals offset from the main diagonal?
You can compute the offset indices explicitly. For example, if you want to assign to the diagonal that is one above the main diagonal, you might shift the linear indices by 1 for each row. In MATLAB, you might do something like:
A(2:n+1:end) = v
for the superdiagonal. The exact pattern depends on how you want to shift with respect to the main diagonal. Alternatively, you can use sub2ind to be explicit about row and column coordinates for each desired diagonal entry.
Can you explain a potential pitfall if the vector is not sized correctly?
If your vector v is longer or shorter than the number of diagonal elements, you risk either running out of elements or leaving some diagonal entries unchanged. MATLAB will throw an error if the number of elements on the left side of the assignment doesn’t match the right side (unless you are using scalar expansion). Always ensure the dimensions match exactly or use a scalar to fill every diagonal entry with the same value.
What if performance still remains slow with vectorization?
In most cases, vectorized operations are faster than looping in MATLAB. However, performance can sometimes hinge on data layout and memory usage. If performance remains a concern:
Check if you’re working on sparse matrices, which might have different indexing considerations.
Profile your code to ensure the bottleneck is really in the diagonal assignment.
Consider other data structures if you constantly manipulate only diagonal elements.
By understanding these subtleties and leveraging MATLAB’s linear indexing, you can efficiently assign values to a matrix’s diagonal without explicit for-loops.