ML Interview Q Series: How would you describe the detailed procedure used in the k-means clustering method?
📚 Browse the full ML Interview series here.
Comprehensive Explanation
The core idea of k-means clustering is to group data points into a fixed number (k) of separate clusters. This approach tries to minimize the within-cluster distance, aiming to place data points that are close to one another into the same cluster. The algorithm involves an iterative process of assigning each data instance to the best cluster and then updating the center of each cluster.
Mathematical Formulation
The standard k-means algorithm seeks to minimize the overall sum of squared distances between data points and the centers of their assigned clusters. One can express this goal through an objective function. It assigns each data point x_i to exactly one cluster j, and each cluster j has a centroid denoted by mu_j. The algorithm searches for the centroids that minimize the sum of squared Euclidean distances.
In the above equation, N is the total number of data points, K is the chosen number of clusters, x_i is the i-th data point, mu_j is the centroid of the j-th cluster, and w_{ij} is 1 if x_i belongs to cluster j and 0 otherwise. The double summation captures every data point and sums up its squared distance to its assigned cluster centroid. The algorithm iteratively adjusts the cluster assignments and centroid locations to reduce this sum.
Initialization of Centroids
Choosing initial centroids has a big impact on how quickly k-means converges and whether it finds a good local minimum. Random selection of k points from the dataset is a common approach, but there are more sophisticated methods such as k-means++ that select initial centroids in a way that spreads them out according to distance from each other. k-means++ usually accelerates convergence and improves the chance of finding clusters that lead to a smaller final sum of squared distances.
Iterative Steps
There is a cyclical pattern of assigning each data point to the nearest centroid and then recalculating those centroids until convergence. In more detail, the algorithm usually goes through an assignment step followed by an update step.
During the assignment step, each data point is associated with the centroid that minimizes the Euclidean distance between the data point and that centroid. Once every data point is assigned, the centroid of each cluster is updated as the mean of the data points in that cluster. This recalculation adjusts the location of the centroid to best represent its assigned data. Convergence is typically declared when the assignments do not change or when the overall displacement of the centroids becomes negligible. Alternatively, a maximum number of iterations can be used to stop.
Convergence Criteria
k-means generally converges when any of the following conditions occur: when the centroid positions do not change, when data point assignments no longer change, or when some iteration threshold is reached. In practice, many implementations stop as soon as the assignments remain the same between two consecutive iterations or when the decrease in the sum of squared distances is below a certain tolerance.
Example Implementation in Python
A simple example with Python and libraries such as NumPy can help clarify how it might be coded. This demonstration code uses random initialization of centroids, performs the iterative assignment and update steps, and stops when assignments stabilize.
import numpy as np
def k_means(X, K, max_iters=100):
# X should be a 2D array of shape (num_points, num_features)
# K is the number of clusters
# max_iters is the maximum number of iterations
# Randomly choose K data points from X as initial centroids
np.random.seed(42)
initial_indices = np.random.choice(len(X), K, replace=False)
centroids = X[initial_indices, :]
for _ in range(max_iters):
# Assignment step: assign each data point to the nearest centroid
distances = np.sqrt(((X - centroids[:, np.newaxis])**2).sum(axis=2))
cluster_labels = np.argmin(distances, axis=0)
# Update step: recalculate centroids based on current cluster assignments
new_centroids = []
for k in range(K):
cluster_points = X[cluster_labels == k]
if len(cluster_points) > 0:
new_centroids.append(np.mean(cluster_points, axis=0))
else:
new_centroids.append(centroids[k])
new_centroids = np.vstack(new_centroids)
# Check for convergence
if np.all(new_centroids == centroids):
break
centroids = new_centroids
return centroids, cluster_labels
This is a basic version and does not implement enhancements such as k-means++ initialization, but it captures the essence of how k-means works.
Potential Drawbacks and Considerations
Although it is widely used, k-means has some shortcomings. It tends to get stuck in local minima if initial centroids are poorly chosen. The user must pre-specify the number of clusters, which is not always straightforward. The algorithm can also be sensitive to outliers and is not ideal for clusters that do not conform to convex shapes. Despite these issues, k-means remains a go-to approach in many practical applications because it is easy to understand, implement, and scales well to large datasets.
How to Choose K
Selecting the right number of clusters (K) is often performed using the “elbow method,” which looks at how the sum of squared distances to centroids changes as K increases. One typically picks K around the point at which increasing K no longer provides a substantial reduction in the sum of squared distances. This technique is heuristic-based and not always conclusive, so domain knowledge and cross-validation methods might be used to gain further confidence.
Handling Large Datasets
When the dataset is extremely large, running k-means on all points can become expensive. Mini-batch k-means is one method to scale the algorithm by updating centroids using small random batches of data at each iteration. This approach significantly reduces computation while retaining decent clustering quality.
Handling Outliers
k-means relies on means for calculating centroids, making it sensitive to outliers that can skew the centroid location. Alternative approaches such as k-medoids or other robust clustering methods can handle outliers better by focusing on the most central points in each cluster instead of the average.
Follow-up Questions
What are common initialization strategies beyond random picking for k-means?
There is a well-known method called k-means++ that selects cluster centers with a probability proportional to the squared distance between the data point and the already chosen centers. This helps spread out centroids in a more informed way, which leads to faster convergence and a better chance of finding a near-optimal cluster configuration. Another strategy is to run k-means multiple times with different random seeds to reduce the chance of converging to a suboptimal solution.
Can k-means handle non-spherical clusters?
k-means fundamentally relies on Euclidean distance and the calculation of arithmetic means, which implicitly favors spherical or convex clusters. If the dataset has elongated clusters, varying densities, or other complicated cluster shapes, k-means might misclassify points. One may switch to other clustering algorithms (like DBSCAN or spectral clustering) or transform the feature space to better align with spherical assumptions.
How do we handle categorical or mixed-type data with k-means?
k-means is naturally defined for numeric data because the computation of arithmetic means and Euclidean distances is less meaningful for categorical features. Mixed-type data might need encoding of categorical variables or dimension transformations. In such cases, specialized variations of k-means (like k-modes or k-prototypes) can be used to accommodate categorical or mixed data.
What is the computational complexity of k-means?
For each iteration, k-means needs to measure distances from each data point to each centroid, which is proportional to NK, where N is the number of data points and K is the number of clusters. Then it updates centroids, which also depends on N (to compute new means). The total runtime is roughly O(NK*T) where T is the number of iterations. In practical applications, T is often relatively small, making k-means quite scalable.
How do we handle empty clusters?
A cluster can become empty when no points are assigned to it in an iteration (often due to noise or poor initialization). One approach is to reassign the centroid to a data point chosen at random, or to the point that is farthest from its current centroid. Another approach is to simply remove that centroid and reduce K by one. However, it is more standard to reposition the centroid to a valid location based on unassigned or outlier points.
These considerations and follow-up details help highlight the nuances of k-means. They demonstrate how a seemingly straightforward algorithm can involve deeper subtleties when applied in real-world scenarios.